Summer 1998
What’s Happening in Pew Projects
Los Angeles, CA
Partners: The Orange County Register, The (Riverside) Press-Enterprise, the Spanish language daily La Opinion, KCET-TV (PBS), KCBS-TV, and National Public Radio affiliates KPCC, KCRW
“The Election Connection,” this year’s “Voice of the Voter” project, found the partners deeply involved in the governor’s race and ballot initiatives throughout the spring. They put several controversial propositions under the microscope. In May, sparked by the debate by the leading candidates for governor, the “Election Connection” included on-line debate coverage, focus groups’ reaction to the candidates’ statements, and roundtable discussions by radio and television partners.
Also in May, KCET-TV hosted a one-hour special featuring a live studio audience on the most hotly contested of the ballot issues, including one to eliminate bi-lingual education in California schools.
The effort was driven by early polling and considerable preliminary coverage from the newspaper partners, with the coalition coming together around specific events to broaden impact among readers, listeners, and viewers.
Madison, WI
Partners: The Wisconsin State Journal, Wisconsin Public Television, Wisconsin Public Radio, WISC-TV(CBS), Wood Communications Group
A frank and emotional conversation on race was the highlight of the April “We the People/Wisconsin – 150 Years and Counting.” An April 3 statewide broadcast featured face-to-face exchanges among the 75 participants present, often with white people pledging to fight racism, and people of color saying whites can’t possibly understand.
The results were distilled into concepts that will be part of a Citizens’ Charter made up of findings from four sesquicentennial discussions on family, race and culture, land use, and work. Among the concepts were: “Americans have difficulty accepting differences” and “Racism is learned.”
The television program earned a 6 rating and a 16 share in the Madison market alone, putting the issue before 32,000 viewers – 16% of Madison’s resident population. The program was re-broadcast in La Crosse, and Duluth-Superior, reaching another 18,000 people. Follow-up is taking place in the “Your Forum” section of the Wisconsin State Journal, and in editorials and stories by the other media partners.
Scheduled for June 20 was “Using the Land,” the third conversation in the series.
El Paso, TX
Partners: El Paso Times, KVIA-TV (ABC), Levi Strauss Foundation, National Park Service
Race, immigration, bi-lingual education, stereotypes, and institutional racism were just some of the topics developed by the El Paso partners in a special series in May based on the theme “Attitudes and Answers: A Survey About Race and Ethnicity.”
With information developed from the most extensive poll ever done on these subjects in the largely Hispanic Texas border town, the El Paso Times and KVIA-TV opened a conversation that was as emotional as it was varied. There was disagreement on the need for affirmative action – with 56% of the Anglos polled saying “No,” while an equal percentage of Hispanics responded “Yes.” (The community is nearly three-quarters Hispanic.) In an open forum on the fourth day of the eight-day effort, a citizen audience of about 160 people concluded that while racism is no longer overt, it is still present in subtle ways and worthy of examination and discussion.
The newspaper series was accompanied by concurrent television coverage of the issues. KVIA followed up with a one-hour documentary on the forum a week later.
Times Metro Editor Robert Moore, who directed the race relations survey, said that discussions on a next step are continuing and include broadening the conversation beyond the local community.
Chicago, IL
Partners: The Chicago Reporter, WNUA-FM, WBEZ Public Radio
Final preparations are underway for an early-summer community conversation on the future of Wrightwood – a changing blue-collar neighborhood in southwest Chicago. Findings of The Chicago Reporter’s case study of Wrightwood’s racial make-up and economics were aired on partner WNUA’ s “City Voices” program May 17.
The community now has nearly equal populations of white and black residents, compared with 1979 when the proportions were 90-10. The Reporter uncovered different perceptions within the community: the mostly elderly white population believed Wrightwood is four-fifths black; most black residents believed racial balance was closer to the actual 50-50. A second example of misunderstanding concerned the late hours of some of the beauty shops patronized by black residents. Some whites had thought that the lights on after dark meant illegal activity, such as drug-dealing. Instead, reporters found that some hair styles, such as braiding, took much longer to complete.
WBEZ-FM plans to air the community conversation. Residents will be invited to talk across color lines about what can be done to preserve Wrightwood as an integrated community.
Aberdeen, WA
Partners: The Daily World, Channel 20 and TCI Cablevision
The “Changing Tides” project leadership poll has turned up a substantial disconnect between traditional community leaders and Twin Harbors residents. The results have touched off some lively discussions concerning leadership, vision, government and life. The spring poll followed up a general poll last year that revealed the complexities and contradictions of what residents said they wanted to preserve and what they wanted to change. The latest findings show that the leaders are not only more pessimistic than the general public but also look to the private sector to lead the way in creating jobs for the area. Almost half the citizens felt that government should be responsible. Four out of five community leaders thought local government represented the people well; less than half the public agreed. While both groups agree the economy is the number-one priority, there was no consensus on how to improve it.
The effort to define a future vision moves next to the conversation stage, as the partners look to bring leaders and people together to find solutions. A town hall meeting at the end of May was the starting point. Smaller “spot” polls and focus groups will be used in the next phase.
Muncie, IN
Partners: The Muncie Star-Press, WLBC-FM, local access cable TV
In June, journalists came together for an intensive study session on Indiana’s proposed tax reform – an attempt to shift the state’s tax base from property to sales or perhaps income. Economics experts from Indiana University, Purdue, and Ball State addressed the group and remained for a public forum that same day. The forum was broadcast live on WLBC-FM and videotaped for playback on local-access cable television.
More citizen sessions are scheduled throughout the summer to provide input when the legislature takes up the tax question in the 1999 session.
Sacramento, CA
Partners: The California Voter Foundation, state news organizations
The California Voter Foundation’s Voter Guide on the web was up and operating a full month before the June primary, featuring information and links for all statewide races and ballot measures as well as congressional and state legislative races, in anticipation of “following the money” in the November general election. The Guide is tracking campaign contributions for U.S. Senator, Congress, eight statewide offices and a hundred legislative seats. Participating news organizations will ask candidates whether they are using the voluntary electronic filing programs set up by the state and the Federal Election Commission, and CVF will spread the word. Candidates who refuse to participate will have their data entered by university students coordinated by CVF.
CVF President Kim Alexander said the web site gives voters control over when and how they get information and includes contact information, ballot measure summaries and campaign and election related links as well as a guide to judicial elections. Says Alexander, “California’s complex ballot can be overwhelming and many voters don’t have time to sort through it all. So http://www.calvoter.org empowers voters by providing independent information accessible 24 hours a day.”
Portland, ME
Partners: The Portland Newspapers, Central Maine Newspapers, WGME-TV (CBS), Maine Public Television, Maine Public Radio
Fresh from the successful “Maine Citizens Campaign,” the partners are moving ahead with “Beyond the Ballot: Maine’s Issues in the New Millennium.”
Driven by a statewide poll administered in five separate regions, the group will highlight how issues and solutions may differ from one area to another.
Separate town meetings will be held in each of the five areas, with citizen input expected to reveal different regional concerns. The gubernatorial candidates are invited to each town meeting, but the organizers will not treat the sessions as campaign appearances. Instead they will be designed as opportunities for the candidates – those who would govern – to listen. The newspaper plans to publish “Beyond the Ballot” stories in its Maine Sunday Telegram each week, with special reports on the progress of the campaign from the citizens’ viewpoint from late August to mid-November. For example the traditional “candidates’ profiles” will this year include the voices of the citizens.
Seattle, WA
Partners: The Seattle Times, KCTS-TV, KUOW-FM, KPLU-FM
The Front Porch Forum launched its ’98 efforts with a package designed to explore in depth longstanding assumptions about growth – whether slowing it or stopping it is possible, and whether it would be wise.
Last year, citizens logged in loud and clear on their misgivings about growth.
They said they didn’t see themselves or their children benefiting from the region’s booming economy. For them, growth meant only higher housing prices, nightmarish commutes and sprawl. One citizen advocated hanging a “Lot Full” sign on the gates of Seattle.
Some 100 citizens wrote, called, or e-mailed to express their opinion in the days following the project kick-off. The county executive asked if he could be involved in any Forum-sponsored citizen discussions on the topic.
The series will explore these themes: 1) Is growth inevitable?; 2) Does growth pay for itself? Should it?; 3) The impact of government economic-development subsidies and growth; 4) Immigration and growth; and 5) Babies and growth.
Idaho Falls, ID
Partners: The Idaho Statesman, The Idaho Falls Post Register, The Lewiston Morning Tribune, The Idaho Spokesman-Review, Idaho Educational Public Television, KTVB (NBC, Boise)
The Idaho coalition is following up their Batten Award-winning “A Collision Course: Prisons vs. Higher Education in Idaho” with “Idaho Speaks Out,” designed to give the people tools to shape the debate in the fall elections. A statewide poll, the largest ever taken in Idaho, has surfaced federal debt, health care costs, taxes, and the schools as key issues.
The coalition is using in-depth stories on these concerns, plus candidate record and profile stories to broaden the discussion beyond the issues of the professional activists and the candidates’ handlers. In addition, the partners are soliciting questions from people and running candidates’ responses.
Bronx, NY
Partners: BronxNet, The Multi-lingual Journalism Program of Lehman College
The Bronx partnership, through their student-published The Bronx Journal, has surfaced underserved populations including the Irish-American and Italian-American communities in the borough.
As one result, the community cable channel BronxNet, through the student-run “News 67” program, staged a live, interactive call-in program in May around the referendum on the future of Northern Ireland. Spokesmen from The Irish Echo were on the panel fielding questions and comments. In another case, an Italian language newscast has been started as part of the response to the community. The newscast is being telecast in Japanese in addition to Italian.